by Kim, Lahey & Killough Law FirmFranchisees as Third-Party Beneficiaries
Franchise attorney Emily Bohan chosen for publication in the prestigious ABA Forum on Franchise Law Journal—explores Third-Party Beneficiary Rights in Franchise Law
Kim, Lahey & Killough attorney Emily Bohan and Hannah M. Leiendecker of the Faegre Drinker firm in Minneapolis, MN published an article in the latest edition of Franchise Law Journal with the American Bar Association. The article, “Franchisees as Third-Party Beneficiaries to Franchisor’s Agreements with Other Franchisees or Vendors” sheds light on the complex world of third-party beneficiary rights in franchising and examines how individuals or entities not directly party to a contract may still enforce its terms under certain circumstances. This article was published immediately prior to the annual meeting of the ABA Forum on Franchising, at which Emily was in attendance last week.
Executive summary:
A significant impact on Dispute Resolution: Third-party beneficiary rights can play a crucial role in franchise disputes, often determining whether a case has any remedy at all. This underscores the importance of understanding these rights for all parties involved in franchise relationships.
Clear Intent: Courts typically require clear evidence that the contracting parties intended to benefit the third party. This high standard emphasizes the need for precise language in franchise-related contracts.
Franchisee Enforcement of Vendor Agreements: In some cases, franchisees have successfully enforced agreements between their franchisor and vendors as third-party beneficiaries. This highlights a potential avenue for franchisees to protect their interests.
Employee “Poaching” Restrictions: Some franchisors have utilized third-party beneficiary rights to limit employee recruitment between franchisees. However, Bohan and Leiendecker note that this practice faces increasing legal scrutiny and potential antitrust challenges.
Rare Vendor Claims: While uncommon, there are instances where third-party vendors have successfully claimed benefits under franchise agreements. These cases often hinge on exceptionally close relationships between the vendor and franchisor.
Highly Fact-Specific Nature: Bohan and Leiendecker emphasize that third-party beneficiary cases in franchise law are typically unpredictable and heavily dependent on specific circumstances. This unpredictability underscores the need for careful contract drafting and legal guidance.
The full article provides a thorough examination of relevant case law and offers practical insights for franchise industry professionals. It serves as a valuable resource for franchisors, franchisees, and their legal counsel in navigating the complex web of contractual relationships inherent in franchise operations.
Bohan and Leiendecker emphasize that these cases are highly fact-specific and often unpredictable. Both recommend that franchisors and franchisees carefully consider potential third-party beneficiaries when drafting contracts. They suggest a proactive approach and recommend that parties mitigate uncertainty and reduce ambiguity by explicitly stating their intentions regarding third-party benefits within their contracts.
The full article, “Franchisees as Third-Party Beneficiaries to Franchisor’s Agreements with Other Franchisees or Vendors,” is available in the current issue of the Franchise Law Journal.
Copyright 2024. Published in The Franchise Law Journal, Vol. 43, No. 3, Fall 2024, by the American Bar Association. Reproduced with permission. All rights reserved. This information or any portion thereof may not be copied or disseminated in any form or by any means or stored in an electronic database or retrieval system without the express written consent of the American Bar Association or the copyright holder.
Emily Bohan is an attorney in the Greenville, S.C. office of Kim Lahey & Killough. Hannah M. Leiendecker is an attorney at Faegre Drinker, practicing in the Minneapolis office.
by Kim, Lahey & Killough Law FirmEmily Bohan named 2024 Women in Business
Congratulations to Kim, Lahey & Killough Greenville Attorney Emily Bohan, named one of the 2024 SC Women in Business in recognition of her outstanding contributions to the legal and business communities in Greenville.
Emily Bohan has served as a leader and mentor to small and medium business owners for years. She has been a member of the Greenville Professional Women’s Forum member since 2011 and has served as an executive board member for the 2017-18, and 2020-2021 terms. Her dedication to empowering women in business and fostering their growth and development has been unwavering.
Her commitment to fostering collaboration and knowledge sharing within the local business community is exemplified by her co-founding of the networking group, a local confidential peer advisory forum My Trusted Advisors. This initiative has provided a valuable platform for small and medium-sized business owners to connect, learn, and grow together.
Emily Bohan’s business acumen is best defined through her experience running the Greenville PuroClean franchise, which she owned, managed and recently sold after 15 successful years. Her firsthand experience in navigating the complexities of running a franchise operation equips her with insights into the myriad of challenges faced by businesses. During her years there she was active and served as a presenter in both PuroClean’s Impact Group and PuroWomen, a women’s growth group. She has Chaired the Greenville Technical College, Environmental, Occupational Health & Safety Advisory Committee since 2022.
“What the public does not see every day is Emily’s determination to not only provide top notch legal representation to her legal clients, but to advance the knowledge base and successes of her peers through the delivery of continuing legal education courses and lunch and learns to educate and uplift those around her. Emily is a true asset to the legal and business communities in Greenville. Her leadership, mentorship, and entrepreneurial spirit are deserving of this recognition and we are proud to have her on our team.”
Emily Bohan focuses her law practice in the areas of business, franchise and employment law and is featured on page 48 of the July issue of Greenville Business Magazine.
by Kim, Lahey & Killough Law FirmEmily Bohan joins Kim, Lahey & Killough
GREENVILLE, SC – Kim, Lahey & Killough Law Firm is pleased to announce the addition of attorney Emily Bohan to the firm’s Greenville, SC, office. Bohan’s law practice focuses in the areas of franchise law, business formation and organizations (including LLC’s and Partnerships), business disputes, alternative resolutions, and labor and employment matters.
Bohan’s firsthand experience in navigating the complexities of running a franchise operation equips her with insights into the myriad of challenges faced by businesses; her own franchise business, PuroClean, will celebrate its 15th year in 2024. As an attorney, Bohan counsels businesses and individuals in all aspects of business law including business formation, contracts, franchise, employment, compliance, licensing, and trademark matters.
In addition, Emily Bohan is a South Carolina certified mediator and is able to assist parties in business disputes to come to a resolution outside of a courtroom.
Bohan earned a Bachelor of Arts in Economics and Legal Studies from the University of California, Santa Cruz and her Juris Doctor from the George Mason University School of Law. She is admitted to practice before federal and state courts within both South Carolina and Virginia.
With offices in Greenville and Charleston, SC and Brevard, NC, the Kim, Lahey & Killough Law Firm is devoted to helping clients establish, enforce, and leverage their intellectual property rights from the Upstate, to the Lowcountry to across the globe.